Numistify guide
Should I Clean My Old Coins? Why the Answer Is No
Almost never. Cleaning removes a coin’s original surface for good, graders can see it, and a cleaned coin is worth less than the same coin left alone. Here is why, and what to do instead.
The short answer: don’t
It is the most common beginner question, and the advice among collectors, dealers and grading services is the same: do not clean your coins. A dull, toned or grimy coin left alone is almost always worth more than the same coin made shiny. If you inherited a collection or found old coins, leave them exactly as they are until someone knowledgeable has seen them.
Why cleaning hurts a coin’s value
It removes the original surface. A coin’s surface — its mint luster and any natural toning built up over the years — is part of what collectors pay for. Cleaning strips it away, and it cannot be put back.
It leaves hairlines. Even a soft cloth drags across the metal and leaves fine scratches called hairlines. They may be hard to see by eye but are obvious under magnification.
Chemical dips count too. A coin dipped too far can look bright without any scratches, but it is still treated as cleaned.
It cannot be undone. Once a coin has been cleaned, that is a permanent part of its history.
How grading services treat cleaned coins
Professional graders such as PCGS and NGC spot cleaning quickly. Instead of a numerical grade, a cleaned coin receives a Details grade — for example, “UNC Details — Cleaned”. The label confirms the coin is genuine and roughly how worn it is, but it also records the cleaning, and the market values it as a problem coin. A cleaned coin is not worthless, but it is worth less than an uncleaned one would have been.
What to do instead
Leave it as it is. Dirt, tarnish and toning are not damage in the way cleaning is.
Have it looked at. Show it to your local coin shop, or research its value with the Red Book, world coin catalogues, auction archives and eBay sold listings; see what is my coin worth?
Never remove a coin from a grading holder. A certified coin should stay sealed.
Professional conservation
Some coins do need help: harmful residue, spots, or active corrosion that is still damaging the surface. For these, the grading companies offer professional conservation, which is a different thing from cleaning. NGC’s sister company, Numismatic Conservation Services (NCS), conserves coins and can then pass them to NGC for grading, and PCGS also offers conservation services.
Keep expectations realistic. Conservation can remove contaminants that threaten a coin, but it cannot undo a previous cleaning, and a conserved coin is not guaranteed a numerical grade. It makes sense mainly for coins valuable enough to justify the fee, and your local coin shop or the grading service can advise whether a coin is a candidate.
Safe handling and storage
Hold coins by the edge, between thumb and finger, never on the faces. Skin oils leave marks that can become permanent.
Work over a soft surface, so a dropped coin is not nicked.
Store coins in inert holders, such as flips or albums sold as PVC-free; soft PVC plastic can leave a damaging residue over time.
Keep them dry, away from humidity and household chemicals.
Questions people ask
Should I clean old coins before selling them?
No. Cleaning removes the coin’s original surface and leaves fine scratches called hairlines. Buyers and grading services can tell, and a cleaned coin is worth less than the same coin left alone. Sell or show it exactly as it is.
What happens if a grading service finds a coin was cleaned?
PCGS and NGC give a cleaned coin a Details grade, such as UNC Details — Cleaned, instead of a numerical grade. The coin is confirmed genuine, but the cleaning is noted on the label, and the coin is valued as a problem coin.
Is there a safe way to clean a valuable coin?
Not at home. For a coin with harmful residue, spots or active corrosion, professional conservation is offered through the grading companies — Numismatic Conservation Services (NCS), NGC’s sister company, and PCGS’s conservation service. It is a specialist job, not a cleaning.
Can conservation undo a past cleaning?
No. Conservation can remove residues, spots and harmful toning, but it cannot restore a surface that has already been cleaned. Such a coin can still receive a Details grade after conservation.
Is toning or tarnish bad for a coin?
Not necessarily. Natural toning is part of a coin’s original surface, and many collectors value attractive toning. Removing it usually lowers the value.
Related guides
How to send coins for grading — choosing a service, and whether a coin is worth the fee.
Need to track your collection?
Numistify is where collectors keep track of what they actually have — coins, banknotes and bullion in one catalogue, with the date, mint mark, grade and cert number on every piece.
It also works out what each item really cost you, with the buyer fees, shipping and grading added in rather than just the hammer price. When you sell, you can see what you made on it.
Free for your first 50 items, and there is no card to enter.